| Competency
|
Definition
|
Student
Skills Standards
for observation and debriefing |
| Team
Work |
Working as
a team to achieve mutual goals, building meaningful and productive professional
relationships regardless of personal differences or resource challenges.
HENRY FORD
said this about an effective team
"Coming together
is a beginning;
Keeping together
is Progress:
Working together
is Success. "
GROUP
WORK
Informal
activity by groups and individuals; Just "do it" (local-in-class teams)
No analysis of progress; both positive and negative results repeat over
time. Informal leaders always lead; non-contributors continue
Activities
and needs structured by Faculty; roles and assignments informally defined
by students;
no descriptive vocabulary TEAMWORK
More formal and defined activity, Faculty rotates membership by one
student each month or activities
are structured by student teams and their changing needs.
Negative results decline and positive results increase for optimum performance.
Temporary & adaptive teams are established as needed, with strong student
input (team membership networks to regional, state-wide, national, international
in virtual environment depending on need)
Team-based
vocabulary ©
Students analyze their own results for improvement and replication of
process. (A
few sentences of analysis at the end of each written project or lab, answering
a specific question) Specialized vocabulary is adopted and used as a tool
for analysis and improvement, for critical thinking or replication on
the job
Why Debrief? How to Debrief? Explore this helpful
website
|
Student
Skills Related to Building Teams
TRUST IS THE
FOUNDATION
Each
member is willing to work toward a shared vision or goal in a context
of individual and shared accountability for defined outcomes
Influence
and leadership rotate depending on the task
Each
member listens and respects others
Differences
of opinion are encouraged and freely expressed
Conflict
is viewed as healthy; is surfaced and managed
Team
Focus is on solving problems, rather than on interpersonal competition
or assignment of blame
Relationship
and task roles are balanced
Risk
taking is encouraged, mistakes are learning opportunities, blame is not
productive
Team
is responsive to internal and external change
Team
performance is periodically assessed through member feedback to one another
in the context of individual and mutual accountability
Members
Complement each other's strengths and compensate for limitations
Members
grow personally and professionally from their association with the team
Results
are greater than those that could be accomplished individually
-
Team members hold a common understanding of the problem to be solved
or of team objectives. Although obvious, this part of the process
may require considerable time, study, and discussion depending upon
the complexity of the issue facing the team and the diversity of backgrounds
and expertise of the team members. All members are brought up to speed.
- Free
and open discussion of ideas is encouraged, so that team members learn
from one another and come to understand different approaches and methods.
Risk taking is encouraged. High-risk, high-payoff approaches are welcome
for consideration. Some ideas will be modified or discarded but the
debate is about ideas, not individuals. Establishing trust is important
in highly effective teams and respect for others' ideas is central
to building that trust.
- The
team respects facts, data, and objective analysis. No one is protected
from critical evaluation of their ideas because of their position
in the organization or because of their expertise. There is no fear
of reprisal or looking good at others' expense. The focus is on problem
solving as opposed to positional bargaining. This is important in
building trust among team members. That conflict will arise is not
only OK, it is necessary. The conflict, however, is about ideas not
individuals; about team performance not about individuals winning
or losing. Learning to separate self from ideas is an important step.
- The
team is accountable for final recommendations and results. Individual
team members have assigned and agreed upon responsibilities and are
accountable for them. The team determines methods of operation, timelines,
resource needs, intermediate objectives, milestones, and periodically
evaluates progress. The team redefines its approach and objectives
as necessary. Early mistakes in the process are favorable to later.
Team decisions are critical; as opposed to decisions made by the team
leader or individual team members and substituted for the team.
|
| Quality |
Doing
the job right the first time, and doing it in a way that meets or exceeds
customer's requirements |
Student
Skills Related to Quality of Work
Correctly
determines what needs to be accomplished
Does
it right the first time
Exceeds
expectations; goes the extra step
Performs
with excellence under pressures of time and multiple tasking
Self-assesses
standards of performance and quality of results
Understands
resource relationships of time and materials to problem resolution
Has
working knowledge of safety standards and/or federal hazardous materials
requirements
Assesses
problem, reinvents approaches, and assembles temporary teams when necessary
for resolution; knows a single individual can't know all the answers,
networks with people and information sources
Documents
results for future, thereby shortening re-entry time for troubleshooting
systems
|
|
Customer Focus
5
Points of Customer Contact and steps to excellence in customer service
for Verizon Technicians
- Call
Ahead, show up on time
- Go
to the Customer ‘s Door before Starting the Job
- Keep
the Customer Informed, answer questions, explain
the repair procedures, explain how long it will take
- do
not delay or extend inconvenience; do extra to fix it on the
first visit
- Close
Out with the Customer; notify when finished and Call the Customer Back
to assure satisfaction and completeness
Let's remember we are all
customers and we all deliver some product so theses principles pretty
much represent what
we expect of those from whom we purchase
products and from ourselves when we
deliver products. Further, as with teamwork, these elements are present
in
our classrooms already. Has anyone ever heard an English faculty member
say, "know your audience" as prelude to writing a paper? Could
the audience
be a customer? The only thing new is that we ask you to make it all
explicit. That is, we want to make sure that our students understand
the
elements of the process they have gone through to satisfy the faculty member's requirements. And that these elements are the same as
those used by
them when they satisfy customers outside of the classroom. If we can
accomplish that, then our graduates will know exactly how and
why to implement the Verizon Points of Contact and Steps to Outstanding
Customer Service when they see them.
|
Satisfying
the needs of customers to a quality standard that builds trust and confidence
for long term relationships through exceptional communication and technical
skills
How
can we deal with these concepts
in
the classroom
First, it isn't necessary to
drill the 5 contact points for customer service into our
student’s heads. After all, we don't attempt to teach specific repair
or installation procedures. Rather we deal with understanding of principles
and their application, technical or otherwise. That’s not to say that
specific Verizon approaches may not be used in the classroom. That’s up
to the instructor, the students, the nature of the topic or project being
covered and the approach to it. But whether or not Verizon specific information
is covered, there can be no doubt that students should walk away from
the program with some understanding of elements essential to good customer
service, or as we say, customer focus.
Who is the customer?
In the classroom the faculty
member may be
thought of as the customer for all kinds of projects, lab reports, research
reports and the like. For lab work, Dominic Ciardullo of NCC has gone
a step further and identified the instructor, the students themselves,
or the whole class as the customer depending upon the nature of the work
and the audience to whom the results are presented. Fred Schoenfeld, also
of NCC, has developed projects that involve two separate cohorts of students
where the newer cohort is the customer of the more advanced group. Other
approaches are in use and still others will be identified as we go along.
What does the customer
(faculty member) want?
Sometimes it’s pretty obvious,
sometimes not. In the early stages of the program many assignments can
be clearly understood from the initial instructions. Later, more complex
assignments should require interaction between students and instructor
to more clearly identify instructor (customer) requirements. Joe Stadtmiller,
of MVCC, assigns communications projects that require this kind of interaction
after the initial assignment is given.
How do we satisfy the customer?
As projects become more complex
during the program we can ask student teams for timelines or milestones
planned on the road to completion of the project. This will provide opportunity
for communication between provider (students) and customer (faculty member)
at various stages of the project, for follow-through on commitments, and
for delivery of a satisfactory product (research report). As we have seen
above, all are elements of good customer service.
How do we know if the customer is satisfied?
Grades for labs and projects.
Grades should reflect how satisfied the faculty member is with the final
product and how it was delivered, including criteria for making the
judgment.
|
Student
Customer Focus Skills
Demonstrates
interpersonal skills & etiquette for building long-term human relationships
Hones
verbal skills to describe problems and solutions thereby instilling confidence
and trust; Can sell ideas & convince, can educate and mentor team
members
Appreciates
diversity in teams and the richness brought to creative problem resolution
Holds
positive personal values; Fair, honest, loyal, confidential, dependable,
leads by example, values others' input, listens actively,
Matches
project needs with appropriate resources; Has
up-to-date knowledge of available intra- and extra-classroom resources
Has
up-to-date knowledge of laboratory procedures and project requirements
for increased efficiency in moving through protocols while solving problems
Resolves
conflicts of interest between teacher expectations, team member expectations,
and project requirements
Applies
all other Course Competency understandings
Uses
alternate resources during technical down-time
Demonstrates
flexibility and adaptability to meet project needs
Includes
team approach to problem solving
The ISO 9000 Standards that deal with Total Quality Management have been
revised to ISO 9000 2000. Increased emphasis on customer focus stands
as one of the major aspects of the revision. The first of the guiding
Quality Management Principles is:
"Focus on your customer - Organizations rely on customers. Therefore,
-
Organizations must understand customer needs
Organizations
must meet customer requirements
Organizations
must exceed customer expectations"
While
the standards apply to organizations large and small, and extensive guidelines
exist to help organizations comply with the standards, the ideas presented
can prove useful in day to day interactions with customers.
Who are our customers?
Although there are several categories of customers, organizational goals
related to customer satisfaction relate to the customer who is the end
user of our product. The purpose of satisfying other internal and external
customers must, in the final analysis, contribute to satisfying the end
user that we are in business to serve.
What
do customers want?
They
want to hear "yes" not reasons why you "can't".
They
want to solve their problems, not yours. They don't really want to hear
about internal machinations that make your job difficult. They want ease
of use. Not just of the equipment or communications systems but also of
the way they access installation and repair.
They want timeliness. Be there to start when you say, repair or install
in the time frame you promise, finish when you said you would.
They want certainty. Consistency, reliability, accuracy. In the people they
deal with as well as in the equipment and systems they purchase. They want
follow through on commitments.
How do we satisfy customers?
We
listen to them, talk to them to be sure we understand their needs or the
nature of their problem.
We communicate with them about what needs to be done, how long it will take,
and when it will be finished.
We meet our time commitments
We do the job. We inform the customer when the job is completed and/or as
it progresses so the customer knows what is going on. We check back to make
sure customer expectations are met. |
| Problem
Solving |
Obtaining and
evaluating information to develop and implement cost competitive solutions
to customer problems in a timely fashion. |
*Adapted
from Benjamin Bloom's Taxonomy|
Student
Thinking Skills
Forms
of knowledge - knowing, low to high
Knowledge
of terminology
Specific
facts
Ways
& means of dealing with specifics
Knowledge
of conventions
Trends
& sequences
Classifications
& categories
Criteria
Methodologies
Universals
& abstractions in a field
Principles
& generalizations/exceptions
Theories
& structures
Comprehension
- low to high
Translation
Interpretation
Extrapolation
Application
Analysis
-low to high
Of
elements
Of
relationships
Of
systematic principles
Synthesis
- low to high
Production
of unique communication
Production
of plan or proposed set of operations
Derivation
of a set of abstract relations
Evaluation
- low to high
Judgments
in terms of internal evidence
Judgments
in terms of external criteria
|
| Project
Leadership |
The process
through which individuals exhibit leadership among their co-workers...both
in their own work groups and beyond... to ensure customer service projects
are completed which exceed customer expectations. |
Student
Project Leadership and resource development Skills
Takes
initiative and accepts responsibility to conclusion of problem resolution;
Has
"can-do" attitude; assumes personal responsibility; self-management
Has
positive self concept; Self Confident
Knows
that no single individual can possess the answers to complex problems;
works with others
Uses
information gathering & analyzing, networking & team building with computer
skills to expedite the process
Remains
in continuous learning mode; Treats problems as opportunities to learn
continuously and remain up-to-date
Can
plan and implement, assess problems, read blueprints and diagrams, understand
technical documentation, estimate and predict, assess systems visually
Completes
in a timely manner and does it right the first time;
Uses
computer project management software
Can
evaluate, organize maintain, interpret, document relevant information,
and feedback results to classroom
Can
assemble temporary teams and gather information to fill resource gaps
in project management
|
| Technical
Expertise and Service Delivery |
Having and
applying knowledge of the Telecommunications Industry, especially up-to-date
core technologies, products and services, in order to deliver these to customers
in a timely and expert fashion. |
Vocabulary,
Roles & Concepts for Debriefing Technical Service Skills
Is
an independent life-long learner; speaks, listens and masters basic academic
skills
Assumes
responsibility for remaining current in telecommunications technologies
Networks
with people and information to resolve problems; works on teams, teaches
others, meets expectations, leads, negotiates and works well with diverse
groups
(SCANS)
Uses
computers and electronic tools with ease
Acquires
and evaluates data, organizes and maintains files, interprets and communicates
information (SCANS)
Selects
equipment and tools, applies technology to specific tasks, and maintains
& troubleshoots equipment (SCANS)
Understands
major concepts and relationships among fields of technical knowledge and
applies knowledge to effective solutions
Knows
how to allocate time money, materials space and team (SCANS)
Converses
with peers and faculty with confidence and appropriate vocabulary
Assesses
problems, facilities, equipment, and resources to produce efficient and
effective solutions
Mentors
less able team-mates to facilitate their growth and development
Understands
social, organizational and technological systems; can monitor and correct
performance; can design and improve systems (SCANS)
|